The Situation
A polar-vortex winter storm swept through a multi-property senior living operator’s portfolio, freezing and bursting pipes across 12 buildings. Water damage was widespread, residents had to be relocated, and multiple properties were knocked out of normal operations at once.
The Problem
The insurance carrier treated each damaged building as its own separate claim, which meant a separate $100,000 deductible for every property. Across 12 damaged buildings, that’s $1.2 million in deductibles before a dollar of recovery. On top of that, the carrier challenged the business-income loss, arguing that because displaced residents were relocated within the operator’s broader portfolio, no real income had been lost. Left unchallenged, that position would have multiplied the operator’s out-of-pocket cost and erased much of the business-income recovery.
What We Did
On the deductibles: We built the case that the freeze was a single occurrence: one weather event, one cause of loss across the portfolio. Occurrence language in the policy should mean occurrence treatment in the adjustment: one event, one deductible.
On the business income: We documented that each affected property was its own legal entity, separate LLCs with their own financials. Income lost to those entities was real, regardless of where individual residents were relocated within the broader organization. A resident sleeping in a sister building doesn’t put revenue back on the damaged property’s books.
The Outcome
The carrier agreed: the freeze was a single occurrence, and a single $100,000 deductible applied to the entire event instead of twelve. That one argument saved the operator $1.1 million in deductibles. The business-income loss was adjusted to reflect the actual losses of the affected entities, not the carrier’s portfolio-wide math.
Why It Matters
Most brokers would have accepted the carrier’s first position (per-building deductibles and a denied business-income claim) and moved on.
That’s the difference between placing a policy and advocating a claim. When the loss happens, the policy language you negotiated and the argument you’re willing to make are what determine the recovery.
Client name and financial details withheld for confidentiality.
Connect With Us
Your mission is to provide exceptional care. Ours is to protect it!